Why do plants look nutrient deficient in alkaline soil?

In alkaline soil, plants often can’t absorb iron (and sometimes zinc) even when there’s plenty in the ground. The result is iron chlorosis: new leaves turn yellow while the veins stay green. Colorado State University Extension says there is no easy, cheap or permanent fix. The best long-term answer is choosing tolerant plants and correcting the conditions that make it worse.

Signs of iron chlorosis

  • Yellow leaves with dark green veins, starting on the newest growth
  • In severe cases, leaves turn pale yellow or almost white

What makes it worse

  • Soil pH above about 7.5 with free lime
  • Overwatering, especially in spring
  • Compacted or poorly drained soil
  • Girdling roots or root damage
  • Too much phosphorus fertilizer

How do I treat iron chlorosis?

Treatment How well it works
Soil-applied chelated iron (EDDHA or EDDHMA) Most effective soil product for alkaline soil. CSU suggests applying before May 1.
Foliar iron spray Greens leaves quickly but is temporary; often needs repeating
Trunk injection Done by arborists; lasts longer, but the wounds can let in decay
Fix watering and compaction Essential, and often overlooked
Replace with a tolerant plant The only long-term solution for badly affected trees

Common mistake

Watering a yellowing tree more. Extra water in heavy soil often makes chlorosis worse.

Sources

Still have a question about your garden?

Ask Keith